On this page
What a Conditional Fee Agreement (CFA) Actually Covers
A Conditional Fee Agreement is a contract between a solicitor and their client in which the solicitor agrees to be paid only if the case succeeds. In plain terms, you pay nothing for the solicitor's time if the claim is lost. If the claim succeeds, you pay the solicitor's base rate for the work done, plus an additional success fee expressed as a percentage uplift on those base costs.
The CFA covers the solicitor's own fees. It does not automatically cover: court filing fees, the cost of expert witnesses, forensic costs such as digital evidence retrieval, travel and disbursements, and, critically, the costs that may be ordered against you if your claim fails and the defendant obtains a costs order. Understanding what sits inside and outside the CFA before you sign is one of the most important steps in the funding decision.
CFAs in defamation cases have historically been the subject of intense litigation between the parties about proportionality and recoverability. Since the Jackson reforms of 2013, the success fee is generally paid by the client from any damages recovered rather than by the losing defendant. This changes the economics of the agreement significantly and is one reason why many CFA-funded claims that would have been commercially viable before 2013 are now more difficult to justify at the lower end of the damages scale.
For a detailed account of how conditional fee arrangements work in defamation cases, including the pre- and post-Jackson differences, the full picture is worth studying before any consultation.
The Success Fee: How Much Extra Could You Owe?
The success fee is set by the solicitor at the outset of the CFA, expressed as a percentage of the solicitor's base fee for the case. The cap on success fees in England and Wales is 100 per cent, meaning a solicitor could charge up to double their standard rate on a successful case. In practice, success fees in defamation cases are typically set in the range of 50 to 100 per cent, reflecting the inherent uncertainty of defamation litigation and the risk the solicitor is accepting.
The success fee is now paid from the client's damages. This has a direct impact on how much of any award you actually receive. If your solicitor's base costs are substantial and the success fee is set at 100 per cent, a significant proportion of a modest damages award could be consumed by the fee. For this reason, solicitors operating CFAs have a strong interest in ensuring that the damages estimate at the outset is realistic. Claimants have an equally strong interest in asking specifically what the success fee will be and how it interacts with projected damages.
Success fees are non-negotiable once the CFA is signed, so the pre-signature conversation is the only point at which a client can compare different firms' rates and ask why a particular fee level has been chosen.
After-the-Event Insurance: The Safety Net You Might Still Need to Buy
After-the-Event insurance (commonly called ATE insurance) is a policy taken out after a dispute arises to protect against the risk of adverse costs if the claim fails. In defamation, where the losing party is routinely ordered to pay the winner's legal costs, ATE insurance is not merely useful; it is frequently essential.
The cost of ATE insurance is assessed by specialist insurers based on the merits of the case, the value of the claim, and the potential adverse costs exposure. Premiums vary widely but can run into several thousand pounds, and they are typically deferred and contingent, meaning you pay nothing unless you win, at which point the premium is deducted from your damages or (in some circumstances) ordered against the defendant.
Some solicitors have arrangements with specific ATE insurers, and some ATE providers will not quote at all unless the solicitor's own assessment of merits reaches a defined threshold. If a firm cannot obtain ATE insurance for your case, that is itself a signal about how strongly they assess its prospects, something worth asking directly rather than discovering after the event.
How Solicitors Assess Merits Before Taking a CFA Case
A solicitor who offers a CFA is taking a financial risk. If your case fails, they receive nothing. This means that CFA offers are only extended to cases where the solicitor's own assessment of merit is sufficiently confident, typically defined internally as a greater than fifty or sixty per cent prospect of success, though the actual threshold varies by firm and by the risk appetite of the particular solicitor.
That assessment involves the same analysis you would hope a solicitor applies to any case: does the statement meet the defamatory meaning threshold; can you satisfy the serious harm test with available evidence; how strong are the likely defences; how identifiable and solvent is the defendant; and what is the realistic damages range relative to the cost of litigation?
Claimants sometimes interpret a firm's refusal to offer a CFA as a rejection of their case. It is more accurate to see it as a single firm's risk assessment. Different firms have different risk appetites and different cost bases. A refusal at one firm does not necessarily mean the case is unwinnable — it may mean that firm's commercial model is not suited to the risk profile of this particular claim.
CFA vs Damages-Based Agreements: Key Differences
A Damages-Based Agreement is an alternative funding structure in which the solicitor takes a percentage of the damages recovered rather than charging by the hour with a success uplift. DBAs in civil litigation are capped at fifty per cent of the total damages recovered, and in defamation this means the solicitor receives a fixed proportion of the award rather than a calculation based on hours worked.
The DBA model aligns the solicitor's interest very directly with the size of the damages award. It can work well in high-value cases where a strong damages outcome is anticipated. It works less well in cases where the primary objective is removal of content and reputational vindication rather than financial recovery, because the solicitor's fee depends on damages, and a case that achieves complete vindication through a public apology with nominal damages may leave both parties undercompensated.
DBAs are less commonly offered in defamation than CFAs, partly because of the complexity of assessing the appropriate percentage uplift, and partly because the damages cap can limit a solicitor's recovery below what they would receive under a CFA structure in high-cost, hard-fought cases.
What Happens to Costs If You Lose Despite a CFA
The CFA protects you from paying your own solicitor. It does not protect you from paying the winning defendant's costs unless you have ATE insurance in place. In contested defamation proceedings, the losing claimant faces the prospect of being ordered to pay not only their own disbursements but potentially a significant proportion of the defendant's legal costs, which in defamation cases involving national newspapers, well-funded organisations, or represented individuals can be very substantial.
The interaction between CFA, ATE insurance, and costs exposure is the financial architecture of the claim, and understanding it before signing anything is non-negotiable. The transparent guide to defamation solicitor fee structures sets out how these components interact and gives realistic cost ranges for cases at different stages.
Questions to Ask Any Solicitor Before Signing a Funding Agreement
Before committing to any funding arrangement, at minimum ask your solicitor the following: What is the success fee percentage, and how was it calculated? What specific risks justify that percentage? Is ATE insurance available, and if so, what is the premium and when is it payable? What disbursements am I personally responsible for regardless of outcome? What are the estimated total base costs if the case proceeds to trial? What are the realistic best, likely, and worst outcomes in terms of damages? And, perhaps most importantly, what adverse costs exposure do I face if we lose, and how exactly is that risk managed?
Solicitors who cannot answer these questions clearly and specifically are either not sufficiently experienced in defamation funding structures or are not being appropriately transparent. Both are disqualifying.




